top of page

When should you increase the weight you lift?

Lifting weights is an integral component of any strength training regimen, aiming to build muscle, increase strength, and enhance endurance. But knowing when to increase the weights you're lifting can be the key to turning a plateau into progress.

This guide delves into the concept of progressive overload, the signs that indicate it's time to up your weights, and the scientific rationale behind these strategies.

A personal trainer cheers on his client as he lifts 164kg during a trap bar deadlift.

Understanding progressive overload

The principle of progressive overload states that for muscles to grow, strength to increase, and endurance to improve, they must be continually challenged by increasing the demands placed on them.

This concept isn't new; it's rooted in the research of sports scientists and has been central to training programs for decades, and it's something I've talked about in a separate post.

Scientific foundations

Progressive overload isn't about making random increases to the weight you lift. Instead, it's about calculated increments that challenge your muscles just enough to stimulate physiological improvements without causing injury. Research shows that for effective muscle adaptation, changes in training volume, weight, and frequency are essential (1).

Signs it's time to increase your weight

Knowing when to increase your weights is critical to applying progressive overload effectively. Here are several clear indicators that it's time to adjust your load:

A close look at three plates locked on a trap bar and ready to use.

1. You've met your rep targets easily

If you're consistently hitting or exceeding the upper limits of your rep target without significant strain, your muscles have likely adapted to the weight. For example, if your target rep range is 8-12 and you're comfortably performing 13-15 reps, it's time to consider increasing the weight (2).

2. Your sets feel easier than usual

A noticeable decrease in the effort required to complete your usual set number at a specific weight can indicate that your muscles are ready for a bigger challenge. This should be assessed over multiple sessions to account for daily performance fluctuations due to external factors like sleep, diet, or stress.

3. You're not seeing physical changes

If your progress in terms of muscle size, strength, or definition has stalled, this plateau can often be overcome by adding more weight. Stagnation in physical adaptation is a common signal that your current weights are no longer providing the necessary stimulus for growth (3). Keep in mind that noticeable changes in muscle mass require time (4-16 weeks), so consider this a long-term measure.

4. You've improved your form

Mastery of the correct technique is crucial before increasing the weight. Good form ensures that the intended muscles are engaged properly and reduces the risk of injuries. If you find that your form with the current weights is consistently good, it’s a safe bet to add more weight.

A man lays on an inclined bench while using a barbell to perform an incline barbell bicep curl.

How much to increase?

The increments by which you should increase your weights depend significantly on the exercise and muscle group involved. Generally, for smaller muscle groups like the biceps or triceps, an increase of about 2-5 pounds is sufficient.

For larger muscle groups like the chest or legs, increases of 5-10 pounds are more appropriate. These guidelines are flexible; the key is to maintain the ability to perform the exercise with proper form (4).

The role of small increments

Incremental adjustments, such as using smaller plates, allow for a more controlled approach to increasing weights, which can help sustain long-term progression and minimize injury risk.

These smaller steps help in adapting to new weights gradually, ensuring that the increase is neither too easy nor excessively challenging.

Evidence-based practices for weight progression

Review of literature

Numerous studies support the benefits of progressive overload applied through small, regular increments in weight. A systematic review in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research highlights that small increases in load can significantly enhance both strength and muscle hypertrophy over time, as opposed to sporadic, larger jumps, which can lead to overtraining and injury (4).

Practical applications

In the realm of fitness, many coaches and trainers recommend a prudent approach to increasing weights, which involves a balance between adequate challenge and the maintenance of perfect form. This strategy not only facilitates continuous muscle adaptation but also prevents the common pitfalls of overtraining.

A man pushes a loaded sled on turf while inside a gym.

When to not increase weight

Even with the right indicators, there are times when increasing weight isn't advisable:

1. If your form suffers

Lifting heavier than you can manage, leading to compromised form, is a recipe for injury. Always prioritize technique over heavier weights.

2. During recovery phases

Post-injury or during deload weeks, it's vital to reduce intensity to allow the body adequate recovery. These periods require maintaining or even reducing weights to prevent setbacks.

3. If you feel pain

Unlike typical muscle soreness, pain during or after lifting is a clear indication that the weights might be too heavy, or the form is incorrect. Listen to your body's signals and adjust accordingly.

Putting it into action

Deciding when to increase the weight in your lifting regimen should be a well-considered strategic choice, based on performance metrics and physical indicators. By applying the principles of progressive overload thoughtfully and consistently, you can maximize your strength gains, enhance muscle growth, and improve overall fitness levels.

Adopting a gradual approach to increases, as supported by scientific evidence, ensures that you continue to challenge your muscles while minimizing the risk of injury. Remember, in strength training, more isn't always better; smarter is better.


Need help getting to the gym?

With tailored advice and support, you can achieve your fitness goals faster and with more confidence. Whether you're looking to build strength, improve your form, or overcome training plateaus, our in-person training services are here to help.

Speak with a personal trainer by visiting today.


More posts

You can also find all our blog posts at, or by clicking the button below.



  1. Delavier, F. (2000). Strength Training Anatomy. Human Kinetics.

  2. Schoenfeld, B.J., & Contreras, B. (2014). The Art and Science of Lifting. Victory Belt Publishing.

  3. Baechle, T.R., & Earle, R.W. (2008). Essentials of Strength Training and Conditioning. Human Kinetics.

  4. American College of Sports Medicine (2010). ACSM's Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.


bottom of page